This explanation of the QBO on netweather got me thinking about these things and solar activity, esp with the media fuss about the Met Office's latest piece of research to appear in Nature Geoscience.
chionomaniac wrote:
The quasi-biennial oscillation (QBO) is a tropical stratospheric wind that travels easterly then westerly over a period for the full cycle of just over 2 years. You are right in suggesting that the westerly winds are known as positive and the easterly winds are negative. The pulse of westerly or easterly winds tend to commence in the upper regions of the tropical stratosphere and push downwards towards the troposphere. This can leave us in a state where the upper winds in the tropical stratosphere are westerly and the lower regions are easterly or vice versa depending on what stage of the QBO we are in. Sometimes these winds can push through and affect the polar stratosphere and other times they do not. The general reading for the state of the QBO mean winds is normally taken at the 30 hPA level.
Generally, it is thought that the stratospheric vortex polar is increased in a westerly QBO regime and decreased in an easterly regime. However the exact timing and positioning of these winds descending the stratosphere is going to have a big influence on polar regions.
Then we also need to take into consideration the Brewer Dobson circulation (BDC). This is the mechanism that transfers ozone from the tropical stratosphere to the polar stratosphere. Labitzke has shown that this mechanism is influenced by the state of the QBO and the amount of solar flux present. An easterly QBO in solar minimum conditions increases the BDC as does a westerly QBO in solar maximum conditions.
Increased polar ozone will lead to a warmer polar stratosphere and a reduced thermal gradient between the polar and tropical stratosphere. This in turn will lead to a reduced polar vortex and a more disrupted tropospheric jet stream.
Then we need to add in to the mix the ENSO state and how this interacts with the state of the QBO and tropical stratosphere and we begin to realise how complex all this is and that to just say a negative QBO is favourable for winter is just a little bit too simplistic!
The table below uses January, February, March to define winter in this case as the core months of the Scottish Snowsports Season. Abbreviations used:
QBO: Quasi Biennial Oscillation
AO: Arctic Oscillation
MEI: Multivariate ENSO Index
ENSO: El Nino Southern Oscillation
The season quality index is 0 to 5, 3 being average, 5 is the exceptional snow seasons like 2010, 2001, 1994 and 1979. 0 is those hall of shame for being right up there as the collection of years making up the worst seasons of all time.
This is of course rather subjective, thoughts on the season rankings welcome. Review of CairnGorm seasons in the Scottish Ski Club centenary journal contributed to season rankings for 1973 to 1992, along with other evidence and personal experience.
JFM JFM Season JFM JFM
Season AO QBO Quality MEI Sunspot Count
1973 0.9 -0.31 1 1.35 48
1974 -0.3 -1.10 1 -1.83 25
1975 0.6 -15.04 2 -0.67 10
1976 0.8 9.28 1 -1.42 11
1977 -1.8 -15.65 4 0.29 16
1978 -1.0 6.21 4 0.87 74
1979 -1.2 2.29 5 0.32 148
1980 -1.5 -6.22 4 0.65 147
1981 -0.7 7.58 2 0.00 130
1982 0.4 -14.63 0 -0.12 143
1983 -0.3 11.47 4 2.88 67
1984 -0.6 -11.66 4 -0.25 75
1985 -1.2 3.38 4 -0.63 17
1986 -0.5 10.28 5 -0.16 13 Hale Winter
1987 -1.5 -11.84 5 1.38 9 Hale Cycle
1988 -0.3 6.61 4 0.75 59
1989 2.6 -2.69 0 -1.16 152
1990 2.5 -4.83 0 0.56 150
1991 -0.2 8.72 4 0.33 148
1992 0.9 -15.04 0 1.87 139
1993 1.5 10.60 3 0.88 73
1994 0.2 -9.59 5 0.23 42
1995 0.6 8.39 3 1.01 28
1996 -0.8 -7.54 4 -0.50 8
1997 0.8 1.05 2 -0.45 8
1998 -0.8 -2.91 0 2.68 42
1999 -0.3 5.84 4 -1.12 66
2000 0.6 4.85 3 -1.17 117
2001 -1.1 -15.74 5 -0.60 97
2002 1.2 7.32 2 -0.14 114
2003 0.2 -2.04 1 0.98 78
2004 -1.0 1.07 2 0.18 50
2005 -0.8 -0.66 2 0.71 34
2006 -0.6 -10.15 3 -0.49 19
2007 0.6 2.09 2 0.54 11
2008 0.8 -4.98 4 -1.33 4
2009 0.1 11.49 3 -0.71 2 Hale Cycle
2010 -2.4 -17.56 5 1.35 11 Hale Winter?
2011 0.4 9.89 4 -1.58 34
Scatter charts of teleconnection values against season index were, well scattered. The QBO one though showed up an interesting pattern:
Good seasons tend to have a well established QBO phase, near neutral/transitional condition of the QBO seems to favour poorer seasons (-5 to +5), though 1979 goes against this, indeed 1979 seems to be a total freak, proof that however various cycles might stack the odds, anything can still happen.
The MEI scatter chart is such a shambles it would seem to imply that ENSO state alone is not significant, yet we seem to have periods where El Nino is good for winter and periods where it's bad - how it interconnects with other factors?
Edited 1 times. Last edit at 13.38hrs Wed 12 Oct 11 by alan.
Attachments:
qbo.png (30kB)